But if they're inside IR35, why would they not get employment rights?

If you're saying they were really employees just pretending not to be, why would you not be paying all of them back pay in lieu of accrued holiday and so on, because as employees they were surely entitled to it?

Deloittes will still sell you consultants, of course, for a lot more than you were paying those who won't work for you any more. I'm not entirely sure those people are going unemployed either - but I suppose time will tell.

Posted By: Old Man on October 17th 2018 at 22:46:50

Message Thread

Anyone ever set up a Ltd company before for contracting work? (General Chat) - Bungle, Oct 17, 20:40:39
- Since the change in IR35 we've seen many contractors/consultants walm away... (General Chat) - Worthing Yellow, Oct 17, 22:07:11
  - The change requires the hiring entity to take a view on the status - is that right? (General Chat) - Old Man, Oct 17, 22:11:33
    - The aim was to avoid any employment rights argument (General Chat) - Worthing Yellow, Oct 17, 22:37:00
      - But if they're inside IR35, why would they not get employment rights? (General Chat) - Old Man, Oct 17, 22:46:50
        
        Consultants on government frameworks aren't employees... (General Chat) - Worthing Yellow, Oct 17, 23:08:00
- It all depends on how much you think you’ll make (General Chat) - Tony Martin, Oct 17, 21:15:51
  - Exactly that^^ (n/m) (General Chat) - archroy, Oct 17, 22:09:25
  - Thanks Tony, with a bit of luck it should be good money. (n/m) (General Chat) - Bungle, Oct 17, 21:22:49
- Check out IPSE (General Chat) - Old Man, Oct 17, 21:11:19
  - Ugh, yeah it’s IT / InfoSec. Thanks OM. (n/m) (General Chat) - Bungle, Oct 17, 21:21:23
  - Crikey (General Chat) - Old Git, Oct 17, 21:13:00
    - Not quite what I said... (General Chat) - Old Man, Oct 17, 21:17:41
      - It’s an obvious fiddle (General Chat) - Old Git, Oct 17, 21:19:03
        
        it's only a fiddle if HMRC proves it (General Chat) - CWC, Oct 17, 21:25:58
        
        Definitely not Lord Templeman ... (n/m) (General Chat) - Old Git, Oct 17, 21:29:35
        
        What is? (General Chat) - Old Man, Oct 17, 21:23:41
        
        “HMRC tell people they owe tax the law simply does not say they owe“ (General Chat) - Old Git, Oct 17, 21:33:04
        
        If you go into a tax scheme you deserve everything you get (General Chat) - Old Man, Oct 17, 21:38:15
        
        Legitimately self employed (General Chat) - Old Git, Oct 17, 21:43:47
        
        The House of Lords didn't agree with you on that (General Chat) - Old Man, Oct 17, 21:51:24
        
        Well there you go (General Chat) - Old Git, Oct 17, 21:56:46
        
        Far from it (General Chat) - Old Man, Oct 17, 22:09:13
        
        Well (General Chat) - Old Git, Oct 17, 22:23:06
        
        And I don't think you can have one status for tax purposes and another for employee rights (General Chat) - Old Man, Oct 17, 22:26:19
        
        No he doesn’t (General Chat) - Old Git, Oct 17, 22:32:11
        
        My bad - thought he said he'd shared a pint with you at some point (n/m) (General Chat) - Old Man, Oct 17, 22:34:56
- Be careful (n/m) (General Chat) - Old Git, Oct 17, 20:53:41
  - Sorry premature send (General Chat) - Old Git, Oct 17, 21:05:19
  - Thanks OG (General Chat) - Bungle, Oct 17, 20:57:13
    - See above! (General Chat) - Old Git, Oct 17, 21:08:15
      - It’s that or the insolvency service! Thanks mate. (n/m) (General Chat) - Bungle, Oct 17, 21:10:58
  - fuck da HMRC (n/m) (General Chat) - Jumbo1, Oct 17, 20:57:08
- Meeky did this when he started out - not sure if he’s back from holiday but can DM him and (General Chat) - Jumbo1, Oct 17, 20:44:15
  - 👍 (n/m) (General Chat) - Bungle, Oct 17, 20:47:20
    - Too many words but may be relevant.... (General Chat) - Jumbo1, Oct 17, 20:52:34
      - I would especially pick out: (General Chat) - CWC, Oct 17, 20:59:00
        
        Employment law is very complex and there are few silver bullets (General Chat) - Old Man, Oct 17, 21:29:46
        
        yeah some interesting cases in the gig economy space at the moment (General Chat) - CWC, Oct 17, 21:36:20
        
        ...and your point on on-the-ground reality vs what the contract says is absolutely key (General Chat) - Old Man, Oct 17, 21:42:29
        
        tax and law. Best. Thread. Ever. (n/m) (General Chat) - CWC, Oct 17, 21:48:14
        
        Go on. Ask me about VAT and derogations. It's my party piece. (General Chat) - Old Man, Oct 17, 21:52:02
        
        Ha! (General Chat) - CWC, Oct 17, 21:58:10
        
        Ta CWC. (n/m) (General Chat) - Bungle, Oct 17, 21:02:42
        
        np (General Chat) - CWC, Oct 17, 21:18:17
        
        Nope that’s me... thanks much xx (n/m) (General Chat) - Bungle, Oct 17, 21:35:22

Reply to Message

In order to add a post to the WotB Message Board you must be a registered WotB user.

If you are not yet registered then please visit the registration page. You should ensure that their browser is setup to accept cookies.