I'm really not sure

Maddison was absolutely incredible in that one season. Great assists, wonder goals, absolutely running the show from midfield. And he has carried on looking an excellent player at one of the best clubs in the Prem.

Buendia has been amazing in the Championship as well, but was a bit inconsistent in the Prem, and was pretty anonymous in our bad run at the end of the season. I'm convinced he and the rest of the team will do much better next season, but it's not absolutely guaranteed.

I'd happily pay extra to watch either - just don't know which would be better for us in the Prem. I'm sure that if Maddison were our current player and we had sold Buendia three years ago, a lot of the responses in this thread would be different.

Posted By: Mecagoenti on May 21st 2021 at 10:01:11

Message Thread

If you could choose Emi or Madders to be in our team next season, who do you opt for? (NCFC) - Azteca, May 21, 09:20:35
- Emi 100% (NCFC) - camcan, May 21, 11:15:29
- Emi (n/m) (NCFC) - Larry Hagman, May 21, 10:45:10
- Wes Hoolahan all day long (NCFC) - Charles21, May 21, 10:38:41
  - Wessi my all time fave BUT Emi is better. However a 28 year old Wes (NCFC) - BINMEN8R, May 21, 10:41:42
    - Agreed. Emi is quite comfortably a better player than Wes ever was (NCFC) - earlydoors, May 21, 11:32:14
    - Emi might be better, but Wes is the best (NCFC) - Charles21, May 21, 11:04:23
      - ^^ VMT ^^ (n/m) (NCFC) - JD3, May 21, 11:21:38
      - And yes, agreed, that would have been sexual (n/m) (NCFC) - Charles21, May 21, 11:05:29
- Emi for sure, never really got the full Madders love... (NCFC) - Worthing Yellow, May 21, 10:25:19
- Maddison (NCFC) - yellowman, May 21, 10:05:32
- Madderz lifting the cup to the Chelsea fans the other day was splendid. (n/m) (NCFC) - DrDublin, May 21, 09:58:12
  - dispassionately (NCFC) - Cardiff Canary, May 21, 10:02:25
    - Yep, hopefully our scouts are on the lookout for the next Emi/Madders. (n/m) (NCFC) - DrDublin, May 21, 10:04:21
- Emi (NCFC) - SimonOTBC, May 21, 09:57:37
  - I think because of his strength and physicality, Emi has a much higher ceiling (NCFC) - jamesward, May 21, 10:01:36
    - Perhaps, but Madders is delivering at a higher level right now (NCFC) - SimonOTBC, May 21, 10:24:00
      - He seems to be injured a lot (NCFC) - camcan, May 21, 11:52:10
      - Is that because is a better player though? (NCFC) - mr carra, May 21, 10:51:08
        
        That's my point to be fair (NCFC) - SimonOTBC, May 21, 10:58:32
- I think there is a bit of revisionism here (NCFC) - Mecagoenti, May 21, 09:36:32
  - Emi is playing in a better all round team with other creators when Maddison was a one man (NCFC) - watfordcanary, May 21, 14:42:18
  - seriously, who would you pay extra to see? (NCFC) - Tombs, May 21, 09:43:15
    - I'm really not sure (NCFC) - Mecagoenti, May 21, 10:01:11
      - so you would walk away from both then? (NCFC) - Tombs, May 21, 10:16:24
        
        not really sure what that means (n/m) (NCFC) - Mecagoenti, May 21, 10:21:37
        
        The original q was who would you chose for next season (NCFC) - Tombs, May 21, 10:32:20
        
        O (n/m) (NCFC) - Tombs, May 21, 10:32:57
      - However, Emi was second only to KDB in chance creation in the Prem (NCFC) - jamesward, May 21, 10:08:41
        
        that's an interesting point (NCFC) - Mecagoenti, May 21, 10:20:37
        
        Pukki and Emi definitely make each other look great (NCFC) - jamesward, May 21, 11:02:50
        
        I also seem to recall Emi giving away a lot of goals last season... (NCFC) - mr carra, May 21, 10:54:24
        
        He did that two or three times, yes (NCFC) - jamesward, May 21, 11:01:22
        
        Is there a stat that shows xG created by each player? (NCFC) - SimonOTBC, May 21, 10:26:53
        
        our results without emi are very poor iirc (NCFC) - Tombs, May 21, 10:52:04
- Definitely Emi (NCFC) - mr carra, May 21, 09:34:24
- Señor Buendia, 100% (n/m) (NCFC) - NxNW, May 21, 09:33:14
- Emi Buendia from Argentina (NCFC) - Bravo win or die, May 21, 09:30:49
  - Maadddiisooonnn - Maadddiisooonnn (n/m) (NCFC) - seminated_woolly, May 21, 11:40:37
  - He did in E Block, but it never really carried.. (NCFC) - Thomo, May 21, 09:43:07
  - just the dreary and tired half arsed rendition of his name sung moronically over and over (NCFC) - Tombs, May 21, 09:40:05
- Emi - no contest (which is saying something) (n/m) (NCFC) - paulg, May 21, 09:26:56
- Emi by a wide margin (n/m) (NCFC) - jamesward, May 21, 09:24:38
- Emi every single time (n/m) (NCFC) - Yellalee, May 21, 09:22:15
  - Definitely Emi (NCFC) - Dog, May 21, 09:23:28

Reply to Message

In order to add a post to the WotB Message Board you must be a registered WotB user.

If you are not yet registered then please visit the registration page. You should ensure that their browser is setup to accept cookies.