I was in Inverness all of last week...
and the interesting thing is it really does seem too close to call now. Everywhere I travelled around the towns in the early part of last week, there were 'Yes' and 'No thanks' signs tied to pretty much each lampost. Having a conversation with locals two years ago, they said the Yes vote would mainly come from the central belt, but the Boarders, Lowlands and certainly Highlands would be mostly in the No camp. I think that was pretty much true 24 months ago, but it's more of an even split now in the Highlands... and as the majority of the "Yes" support remains in the central-belt, you can see why and where this increasing support for Independence is coming from now. The long-undecideds are starting to nail their colours to the mast too.
British politicians have to come to terms with the fact that this was never ever going to be a political question. The question of a country's Independence to their people has nothing whatsoever to do with politics. Policies and politics come afterwards in the fall out over a decision of Independence. I actually think it could be too late for the 'No' campaign now. Voters will not be swayed by promises of more devolved power from Westminster. Balls seems to think that by Scots choosing to vote 'Yes' is a protest vote against the unpopular policies of a coalition government. Wrong, Edward. It's about the pride and long history of a nation, and over 300 years of interference from south of their boarder. That's the argument the "Yes" campaign has centered around, rather than the details of political and economic logistics. It's no wonder the lack of charisma and promises of more or less of the same from the UK, from the "No" campaign, have uninspired and fallen on deaf ears.
However, the biggest trouble for the "No" campaign now is that this has become an operation to save the Labour Party. A Yes vote will remove Scottish Labour MPs from Westminster, and by removing their substantial voted support, will effectively obliterate the Party from ever having the majority support to govern again. That's why Darling, Brown, Miliband, Prescott, Balls, and other English and Welsh Labour MPs are touring every square inch of Scotland between now and voting day.
The most interesting and telling thing for me being in Scotland last week, is that by yesterday when I travelled home, a lot of the same "No thanks" signs that I'd seen on lamposts when I'd arrived, had been torn down. Suddenly I was seeing a lot more Yes than No.
Interesting times ahead...
Posted By: Jim Nasium on September 8th 2014 at 11:39:42
Message Thread
- In light of the recent news stories have been reading a bit about this Scottish referendum (NCFC) - Jim, Sep 8, 10:22:49
- I was in Inverness all of last week... (NCFC) - Jim Nasium, Sep 8, 11:39:42
- the more English Labour campaigns for 'No' (NCFC) - CWC, Sep 8, 11:55:14
- Its the labour party not being able to secure their own vote that (NCFC) - Jim, Sep 8, 12:02:27
- the more English Labour campaigns for 'No' (NCFC) - CWC, Sep 8, 11:55:14
- Quite right (NCFC) - paulg, Sep 8, 11:26:24
- "do it on a properly informed basis in terms of what it means for both side of the border. (NCFC) - Ralf Scrampton, Sep 8, 11:13:07
- What would you have had our idiot hapless politicians do differently? (n/m) (NCFC) - Tricky Hawes, Sep 8, 10:36:32
- Not be so complacent and knock on the head some of the questionable claims the SNP keep (NCFC) - Jim, Sep 8, 10:44:30
- I think they've been trying to do that for the past 6 months. (n/m) (NCFC) - Tricky Hawes, Sep 8, 10:50:36
- It's been a rubbish campaign by Better Together for all sorts of reasons (NCFC) - Old Git, Sep 8, 11:02:33
- If England offered no VAT on deep fat fryers. It would all be over an hour into the vote (NCFC) - pants, Sep 8, 13:28:09
- More eloquently put, and in many less words than I. (n/m) (NCFC) - Jim Nasium, Sep 8, 11:41:45
- precisely this (NCFC) - Basil Wrathbone, Sep 8, 11:08:10
- It's been a rubbish campaign by Better Together for all sorts of reasons (NCFC) - Old Git, Sep 8, 11:02:33
- I think they've been trying to do that for the past 6 months. (n/m) (NCFC) - Tricky Hawes, Sep 8, 10:50:36
- Not be so complacent and knock on the head some of the questionable claims the SNP keep (NCFC) - Jim, Sep 8, 10:44:30
- I have a hunch that the 'yes' bounce is probably about as real as the Nick Clegg bounce (NCFC) - norway, Sep 8, 10:27:13
- I really, really hope you're right - like Quebec (NCFC) - Old Git, Sep 8, 10:56:04
- The intesrting tag line in the polls is "excluding the undecideds" but (NCFC) - Jim, Sep 8, 10:59:25
- Possibly. Do often get it a week or two ahead of the vote and then it scares all the (NCFC) - Jim, Sep 8, 10:31:33
- I really, really hope you're right - like Quebec (NCFC) - Old Git, Sep 8, 10:56:04
- I was in Inverness all of last week... (NCFC) - Jim Nasium, Sep 8, 11:39:42
Reply to Message
In order to add a post to the WotB Message Board you must be a registered WotB user.
If you are not yet registered then please visit the registration page. You should ensure that their browser is setup to accept cookies.