how do you know that?

the one you bring on depends on the state of the game. Maybe a player was injured, which they couldn't have predicted.

Impossible to know whether the one they brought on would have been on the bench.

There's a question of whether they should be docked *more* than the point they gained - is the punishment should be punitive, to deter people from actually cheating. (Otherwise the worst that can happen is that you don't get any points from a game - not much of a disincentive.)

But they definitely shouldn't have kept the point they got from that game.

Posted By: Tricky Hawes on April 22nd 2008 at 17:23:18

Message Thread

so what if (NCFC) - south, Apr 22, 16:00:49
- we'd look like right prats if we made a fuss (NCFC) - mr carra, Apr 22, 16:16:50
  - None of the precedents were equivalent though (NCFC) - Jim, Apr 22, 17:35:22
  - how do you know that? (NCFC) - Tricky Hawes, Apr 22, 17:23:18
  - Precedents don't alter the fact that the rule is pointless (NCFC) - yarmyyarmy, Apr 22, 16:28:10
    - It wouldnt surprise me if Wednesday did it again (NCFC) - phrankin, Apr 22, 16:32:40
      - we could too (NCFC) - mr carra, Apr 22, 16:36:27
        
        we could have a stronger bench ( Do we even have 6 loanees now?) (n/m) (NCFC) - phrankin, Apr 22, 16:37:44
        
        No, because we had to send one back (NCFC) - Tricky Hawes, Apr 22, 17:20:36
        
        ^^^ not quite true (NCFC) - blindasabat, Apr 22, 17:29:55
    - I presume the poenalty would be more severe if all the loan players actually played (n/m) (NCFC) - mr carra, Apr 22, 16:31:33
      - In which case, just have that as the rule and leave the other clause out. (n/m) (NCFC) - yarmyyarmy, Apr 22, 16:33:37
        
        I agree totally (NCFC) - mr carra, Apr 22, 16:35:34
  - à la Sheff Utd last year (n/m) (NCFC) - Yellalee, Apr 22, 16:18:53
    - Sheffield United had a decent case however (NCFC) - phrankin, Apr 22, 16:24:12
      - But they weren't worried until it affected them. Same as us. Stoke wouldn't (NCFC) - Yellalee, Apr 22, 16:27:17
        
        But almost everyone agreed with Sheffield, I guess the FA were happy (NCFC) - phrankin, Apr 22, 16:31:53
        
        what do mean by use them? (NCFC) - mr carra, Apr 22, 16:34:19
        
        give you a stronger bench of course (NCFC) - phrankin, Apr 22, 16:35:55
    - exactly (n/m) (NCFC) - mr carra, Apr 22, 16:20:46
- Or in fact if they send us down on goal difference (n/m) (NCFC) - Jim, Apr 22, 16:02:06

Reply to Message

In order to add a post to the WotB Message Board you must be a registered WotB user.

If you are not yet registered then please visit the registration page. You should ensure that their browser is setup to accept cookies.