Oh come on, for God's sake

Yes the bloke kicked him (not very hard) on the shin. Yes, because of that, it was probably a penalty. But the force of the kick was not enough to cause Henry to fall over.

Earlier in the competition something almost identical happened to Rooney and he stayed on his feet and tried to score. is this an example of english players being "too honest" or was Henry an example of some players "cheating"?

That all depends on how you want to see the game played and probably whether you play professionally or as an amateur.

Simple question which I'm not sure is even covered in the rules:

Is it a penalty if there's "contact" or is it only a penalty if the contact impedes the player? In my opinion, the contact did not impede Henry, he simply decided to fall over having felt the contact.

Posted By: WorthyHatesFans on July 6th 2006 at 09:51:45

Message Thread

So in the cold light of day the verdict is (Other Football) - Old Git, Jul 6, 09:34:40
- If it's a foul in the box it's a penalty. (Other Football) - Dog, Jul 6, 09:47:27
  - Hey, don't snarl at me, dogbreath, I'm got no problem with the pen (Other Football) - Old Git, Jul 6, 10:26:10
  - Oh come on, for God's sake (Other Football) - WorthyHatesFans, Jul 6, 09:51:45
    - engluish player being too honest (under the current FIFA rules) (n/m) (Other Football) - phrankin, Jul 6, 10:02:46
    - disagree (Other Football) - mr carra, Jul 6, 09:55:38
      - Christ, I haven't analysed it THAT closely (Other Football) - WorthyHatesFans, Jul 6, 09:57:38
  - totally, he was tripped in the box - whether he went down or not it was a foul (n/m) (Other Football) - phrankin, Jul 6, 09:48:56
    - Everyone agrees with that (Other Football) - Partial Angler, Jul 6, 09:49:41
- good work Henry - win at all costs against the cheating bastards (n/m) (Other Football) - phrankin, Jul 6, 09:43:55
- How can these people say that they haven't dived (Other Football) - WorthyHatesFans, Jul 6, 09:37:23
  - Yeah, that's what gets me too. (Other Football) - Partial Angler, Jul 6, 09:42:03
  - they wouldn't last 10 minutes on the pitch these days (Other Football) - mr carra, Jul 6, 09:40:15
    - Yes but they could inflict some damage on the ladyboy (Other Football) - WorthyHatesFans, Jul 6, 09:42:26
      - agree with all that! (n/m) (Other Football) - mr carra, Jul 6, 09:44:00
      - Can't disagree. Bring back Muscat... (Other Football) - Partial Angler, Jul 6, 09:43:17
        
        interestingly refs for both semis were excellent (Other Football) - mr carra, Jul 6, 09:49:16
        
        Bring back Muscat (Other Football) - WorthyHatesFans, Jul 6, 09:45:50

Reply to Message

In order to add a post to the WotB Message Board you must be a registered WotB user.

If you are not yet registered then please visit the registration page. You should ensure that their browser is setup to accept cookies.