I don't think everyone should pay the same, I see the principle behind taxing the rich

I don't mind income tax (actually I do, but you know what I mean). The more you earn, the more you pay, all logical and principled

What I think is unfair and unprincipled is the idea that after you've earned it, and been taxed on it, you can then be taxed again just for having spent your money on a particular asset. So you can buy several houses below ?2m, or buy shares, or racehorses, or art, or diamonds, or fine wine, or Bugattis, or helicopters or whatever - no tax. But buy a house worth more than ?2m and you get taxed (again). It's utterly illogical and unprincipled

Posted By: Old Git on September 21st 2011 at 13:32:00

Message Thread

FAO Scrampton (General Chat) - Old Git, Sep 21, 11:05:18
- Talking of mansions, me, Tabitha, Torquil and Bernadette were up at Piers and Annunziata's (General Chat) - malkybarkid, Sep 21, 11:31:05
  - haha (n/m) (General Chat) - Brandonio, Sep 21, 16:24:21
  - I hate it when i get.. (General Chat) - kenny powers, Sep 21, 12:11:35
  - Chuckle (General Chat) - Old Git, Sep 21, 11:40:34
  - haha (n/m) (General Chat) - Arizona Bay, Sep 21, 11:38:28
  - lol (n/m) (General Chat) - jafski, Sep 21, 11:34:31
- a tax on the value of properties already exists (council tax) (General Chat) - Ralf Scrampton, Sep 21, 11:24:45
  - Or valuing second homes? Or valuing cash? Or valuing share portfolios? (General Chat) - Old Git, Sep 21, 11:27:09
    - it might be difficult near the threshold, but not for the really expensive stuff (General Chat) - Ralf Scrampton, Sep 21, 11:33:21
      - Or bring back the Poll Tax and then everyone pays the same (General Chat) - EtuWHO, Sep 21, 12:40:10
        
        I don't think everyone should pay the same, I see the principle behind taxing the rich (General Chat) - Old Git, Sep 21, 13:32:00
        
        so VAT should be scrapped n'all? (n/m) (General Chat) - Ralf Scrampton, Sep 21, 13:43:09
        
        Hmmm (General Chat) - Old Git, Sep 21, 13:59:57
        
        it is a tax dependent on what you choose to buy, despite you having already paid tax on ea (General Chat) - Ralf Scrampton, Sep 21, 14:23:32
        
        I would reduce tax to 5% of earnings (General Chat) - EtuWHO, Sep 21, 14:35:05
        
        VAT is a tax at the moment of purchase - we've already got that for houses (stamp duty) (General Chat) - Old Git, Sep 21, 14:32:59
        
        right... so it's the ongoing nature you dislike (which you failed to mention in your post) (General Chat) - Ralf Scrampton, Sep 21, 14:37:15
        
        Given that we already have a purchase tax (stamp duty) which you seem to have forgotten (General Chat) - Old Git, Sep 21, 14:58:21
        
        the overriding principle behind this tax is the more expensive the house you own the more (General Chat) - Ralf Scrampton, Sep 21, 15:19:15
        
        Rent it out to a Somali asylum seeker (General Chat) - Astroturf, Sep 21, 15:10:11
        
        Git for PM (n/m) (General Chat) - EtuWHO, Sep 21, 14:35:28
        
        Intelligent & Lib Dem? Nah does that work (n/m) (General Chat) - EtuWHO, Sep 21, 14:09:36
        
        Scrammers obviously is intelligent (General Chat) - Old Git, Sep 21, 14:17:33
        
        That is the Clegg effect (n/m) (General Chat) - EtuWHO, Sep 21, 14:24:04
        
        VAT is the fairest tax of all as the more you spend the more you pay (n/m) (General Chat) - EtuWHO, Sep 21, 13:55:01
        
        Excellent idea... (General Chat) - woody, Sep 21, 13:23:41
        
        because it might be that Daddy bought your house for you (General Chat) - Ralf Scrampton, Sep 21, 12:44:27
        
        And what if Daddy had worked hard? (n/m) (General Chat) - EtuWHO, Sep 21, 12:51:34
        
        and what if he didn't? (n/m) (General Chat) - Ralf Scrampton, Sep 21, 13:03:18
        
        Are you trying to say (General Chat) - EtuWHO, Sep 21, 13:53:53
        
        this is an additional tax - not to do with 'all tax laws' (n/m) (General Chat) - Ralf Scrampton, Sep 21, 14:25:13

Reply to Message

In order to add a post to the WotB Message Board you must be a registered WotB user.

If you are not yet registered then please visit the registration page. You should ensure that their browser is setup to accept cookies.