Can Knapper be trusted with the summer window?

I've rated last seasons signings below. Did he just get lucky with a couple? As we need to add quality over numbers I'd be much happier with Clement picking the players. Who have I got wrong?

Kvistgaarden - 5/10 - I really like the guy and he tries but hasn't shown quality and not clear where he ever fitted. Even less so in Clement's team.

Diallo - 4/10 for all the injuries. Another Forson?

Topic - 5/10 could Clement work his magic?

Mattson - 9/10 lucky break? Hard to believe he was second choice behind Topic.

Toure 8/10 on impact so far and clearly massive potential. Does look lost at times so is it just Clement magic?

Wright - 5/10 gone backwards massively and not improving under Clement.

Kovacevic - 6/10 the good and great overshadowed by inconsistency. Not good enough to be a keeper for a top champs team for me.

Ahmed 7/10 for impact but very predictable and risk he is found out next season.

Medic 4/10 so slow and cumbersome. Not sure what anyone saw in him.

Makama 9/10 brilliant and improving but clearly bought for the future so does Knapper get all the credit?

Grimshaw 6/10 seems adequate back up goalie and upgrade on Long.

Darling 5/10 going backwards and concentration not good enough.

Schlupp 3/10 Maybe unlucky with injuries

Maghoma 8/10 could be the best but fitness concerns.

Posted By: Kangol Canary, May 4, 10:58:26