You say that about Mbokani

but he has quite often offered very little when he has started. He doesn't have the pace to stretch defences, nor does he time his runs well enough to beat an offside trap. Too often he's marked out of the game when in the opposition's box, or loses the ball with his back to goal.

There's no doubt that he's a better finisher, the best at the club, and if you give him a chance on a plate in space he will probably score, but he rarely gets into those situations to even have a chance. People moan that Jerome misses a lot of good chances and rightly so, but he has the ability to allow others to create regular chances for him. Then there's the other side of the coin where you get people on here moaning that we don't create the chances for Mbokani to score. The truth is his lack of general ability makes it too easy for centre backs to keep him in their pockets. We need a striker with Jerome's all round ability in terms of movement, plus Mbokani's finishing skill. That's without even daring to ask for that option to even have a good touch or be skillful. That's how poor our options are that an average striker would be a HUGE improvement.

Bamford hasn't played because he's not good enough... yet. He doesn't even offer what Jerome or Mbokani do at THIS level. He struggled to get into the Palace team despite their mediocre striker options, yet when he was given a go he missed good chances. He's a kid that needs to fill out a bit more (you need strength if you're not particularly fast at this level) and gain some real nous before he can be effective at this level.

As far as Naismith goes I agree that we should have tried him up front as he has great movement (unlike Mbokani) and is a decent finisher (unlike Jerome), although he lacks pace (unlike Jerome) and any real technical ability on the ball. He hasn't worked as a 10, but surely can't be worse any than any of our 9's. Again it's a lucky dip rather than a sure fire thing. I really don't envy Alex Neil's task of finding a regular goal scorer given those options, although it was his fault for buying Naismith.

Posted By: Common Sense Police on May 10th 2016 at 16:41:21

Message Thread

Who Scored have done a look at our strikers (NCFC) - King, May 10, 15:19:35
- Well at this stage... (NCFC) - mr carra, May 10, 15:54:45
- "Who Didn't Score" (n/m) (NCFC) - Old Git, May 10, 15:37:27
  - Ha (NCFC) - King, May 10, 15:41:23
- Obvious to all or at least most on here so... (NCFC) - loz, May 10, 15:21:53
  - If you actually read the article it explains why (NCFC) - Common Sense Police, May 10, 16:02:06
    - You've seen a lack of any dribbling ability? I've seen someone who's good with the ball at (NCFC) - Higher Wrather, May 10, 18:49:47
      - Watch him run with the ball at players or over a good distance (NCFC) - Common Sense Police, May 10, 19:17:44
    - To a point... (NCFC) - loz, May 10, 16:16:32
      - You say that about Mbokani (NCFC) - Common Sense Police, May 10, 16:41:21
        
        I think Mbok is fantastic at holding the ball up (NCFC) - maidstoneyellow, May 10, 16:46:51
        
        He has good strength to hold up the ball (NCFC) - Common Sense Police, May 10, 16:58:00
    - Oooooooooooooh... (NCFC) - bird table, May 10, 16:05:54

Reply to Message

In order to add a post to the WotB Message Board you must be a registered WotB user.

If you are not yet registered then please visit the registration page. You should ensure that their browser is setup to accept cookies.