Yes.

You can justifiably claim Adams doesn't have the right experience as he's only worked with kids but can't really have it both ways and claim Phelan isn't experienced either.

Phalan's been an important voice in the dressing room for Champions League finals ffs!

Posted By: lurd on November 23rd 2014 at 10:43:23

Message Thread

Do we think that Phelan would do a good job as manager? (NCFC) - Jacksons_Twelfth, Nov 23, 09:53:50
- football management is not that predictable (NCFC) - Charles21, Nov 23, 11:11:17
  - Good point (NCFC) - Winged Eel Creosote, Nov 23, 11:17:05
    - I'm talking about Phelan (NCFC) - Charles21, Nov 23, 11:20:21
- I'd take pulis. Proven experience at what we need, promotion followed by consolidation (NCFC) - Tony Martin, Nov 23, 10:51:21
- Phelan may not have managerial experience but his general level of experience (NCFC) - Jim, Nov 23, 10:14:20
  - Trouble with argument re experience is the number who do make it . (n/m) (NCFC) - trustsec, Nov 23, 10:29:54
    - It's partly about experience but its also about leadership qualities (NCFC) - Jim, Nov 23, 10:33:19
      - Doubt it, this lot look like poor mans Arsenal and Wenger obviously has same problem. (n/m) (NCFC) - trustsec, Nov 23, 10:38:54
        
        Yep and no shock that all Wenger's success came when he had leaders all over the pitch. (NCFC) - lurd, Nov 23, 10:45:19
- I DO NOT WANT PUBIC CLUBSHOP COMING HERE (n/m) (NCFC) - Dandy Highburyman, Nov 23, 10:11:32
- Don't know but wouldn't want to take yet another huge gamble (NCFC) - Mickdundee, Nov 23, 09:57:20
- Why would Pulis even come here? (NCFC) - lurd, Nov 23, 09:55:15
  - Oh and to answer your point, for every Meulensteen there is a McLaren. (NCFC) - lurd, Nov 23, 09:57:53
    - Is there? I'd suggest that most Assistants / Coaches who take the top job will fail. (n/m) (NCFC) - Jacksons_Twelfth, Nov 23, 10:04:19
      - History (n/m) (NCFC) - Jacksons_Twelfth, Nov 23, 10:08:27
      - Surely most managers are assistants/coaches first (n/m) (NCFC) - Adster, Nov 23, 10:08:04
        
        If you look at the top teams in the prem. (NCFC) - lurd, Nov 23, 10:17:01
        
        presumably the vast majority of those were working with the first team at a big club (NCFC) - Mecagoenti, Nov 23, 10:36:38
        
        Jackson was talking about Phelan who's been working with the first team at arguably THE (NCFC) - Adster, Nov 23, 10:40:26
        
        Yes. (NCFC) - lurd, Nov 23, 10:43:23
        
        exactly - but in the original post he compared Adams to Phelan (NCFC) - Mecagoenti, Nov 23, 10:45:16
        
        Yep ^^^ (n/m) (NCFC) - Adster, Nov 23, 10:20:47
        
        Granted, but lots fail (n/m) (NCFC) - Jacksons_Twelfth, Nov 23, 10:09:38
      - Based on what? (n/m) (NCFC) - lurd, Nov 23, 10:06:13
  - ???'s (n/m) (NCFC) - Jacksons_Twelfth, Nov 23, 09:55:53
    - Does he need it? (NCFC) - lurd, Nov 23, 09:59:47
      - If he came to us it would be because he thought he would be back in the Prem next season. (NCFC) - Jacksons_Twelfth, Nov 23, 10:02:33
        
        It's a risk to his reputation though. (NCFC) - lurd, Nov 23, 10:04:23
        
        That would be the Board's job to change his mind. If they have considered Adams future and (NCFC) - Jacksons_Twelfth, Nov 23, 10:06:10
        
        Well that's something we don't know as well. (NCFC) - lurd, Nov 23, 10:07:54
    - We won't be doing that (n/m) (NCFC) - Mickdundee, Nov 23, 09:58:02
      - In which case we may as well stick with Adams. (NCFC) - Jacksons_Twelfth, Nov 23, 10:01:03
    - We should be making him an offer that he can't refuse. (n/m) (NCFC) - Jacksons_Twelfth, Nov 23, 09:56:43

Reply to Message

In order to add a post to the WotB Message Board you must be a registered WotB user.

If you are not yet registered then please visit the registration page. You should ensure that their browser is setup to accept cookies.