You implied when saying it was the correct decision that the referee acted correctly

There was shirt pulling and the offence of the penalty

At least one yellow had to be shown

Which wasn't, which is why I asked the question, because it looked like you were saying Dowd acted correctly in the decision making

In future, maybe you could be clearer :)

Posted By: pants on February 28th 2010 at 17:09:16

Message Thread

Just seen the Vidic incident for the 1st time (Other Football) - Charles21, Feb 28, 15:53:52
- Well I'm with Sheera on this one, (Other Football) - NCFC4life, Feb 28, 16:08:20
- Well I'm with Sheera on this one, (Other Football) - NCFC4life, Feb 28, 16:07:22
  - I'm glad Shearer disagrees with me (Other Football) - Charles21, Feb 28, 16:10:12
  - oh no (n/m) (Other Football) - Tombs, Feb 28, 16:08:28
- Well I'm with Sheera on this one, (Other Football) - NCFC4life, Feb 28, 16:07:05
  - oh no (n/m) (Other Football) - Tombs, Feb 28, 16:07:56
- So why would anyone ever get sent off in that situation? (Other Football) - yarmyyarmy, Feb 28, 16:04:07
  - the rule is to prevent situations where a striker is clean through (Other Football) - Charles21, Feb 28, 16:06:10
    - No, that's a rule you've just made up (n/m) (Other Football) - yarmyyarmy, Feb 28, 16:10:08
      - I remember when the rule came in (Other Football) - Charles21, Feb 28, 16:10:49
        
        you must be mister memory man the memory master of the universe then (Other Football) - Tombs, Feb 28, 16:16:58
        
        The concept was introduced in football after an infamous incident in the 1980 FA Cup Final (Other Football) - Charles21, Feb 28, 16:18:43
        
        oh YEAH!! I DO remember that now! (Other Football) - Tombs, Feb 28, 16:25:32
        
        I certainly won't be correcting you (Other Football) - Charles21, Feb 28, 16:37:18
        
        phew, that's ok then (Other Football) - Tombs, Feb 28, 16:20:35
        
        I need a google hand.... is it good for finding things in your pockets? (n/m) (Other Football) - Pixelman, Feb 28, 16:23:54
        
        i'm typing from memory as i left my gregory pies in the car (n/m) (Other Football) - Tombs, Feb 28, 16:26:22
        
        you try some of these..... (Other Football) - Pixelman, Feb 28, 16:28:34
        
        good lord (n/m) (Other Football) - Tombs, Feb 28, 16:30:38
        
        someone stole my 'should' - it was there when I typed and hit submit.... ?? (n/m) (Other Football) - Pixelman, Feb 28, 16:29:52
    - spot on (Other Football) - SCC 28, Feb 28, 16:07:08
  - I agree (Other Football) - duke of york, Feb 28, 16:05:39
- So is shirt pulling allowed these days? (n/m) (Other Football) - pants, Feb 28, 15:57:35
  - I'm talking about the decision not to send him off (Other Football) - Charles21, Feb 28, 15:59:26
    - I didn't (n/m) (Other Football) - pants, Feb 28, 16:11:50
      - oh, well the question doesn't make sense then? (Other Football) - Charles21, Feb 28, 16:13:34
        
        You implied when saying it was the correct decision that the referee acted correctly (Other Football) - pants, Feb 28, 17:09:16
  - defo not hence he gave a penalty (n/m) (Other Football) - SCC 28, Feb 28, 15:57:56
    - TAG TEAM! (n/m) (Other Football) - pants, Feb 28, 15:58:43
      - well why ask such stupid questions? (n/m) (Other Football) - SCC 28, Feb 28, 15:59:20
- Yes (Other Football) - duke of york, Feb 28, 15:55:43
- yes (Other Football) - Tombs, Feb 28, 15:55:16
  - I will take it the wrong way (Other Football) - Charles21, Feb 28, 15:56:59
    - I bloody well won't! (Other Football) - Tombs, Feb 28, 15:58:07
      - thank the lord (n/m) (Other Football) - Charles21, Feb 28, 15:59:55
        
        Don't mention it (n/m) (Other Football) - Tombs, Feb 28, 16:00:36
- he never scores from that angle (Other Football) - SCC 28, Feb 28, 15:55:12
  - goalscoring opportunity is a ridiculous phrase (n/m) (Other Football) - Charles21, Feb 28, 15:58:49

Reply to Message

In order to add a post to the WotB Message Board you must be a registered WotB user.

If you are not yet registered then please visit the registration page. You should ensure that their browser is setup to accept cookies.