Don't fully agree with that, altho almost
Mostly fair enough, obviously, and the Irish are clearly whingeing. But -
(1) I'd have thought the fairest solution would be to seed the play-offs, but on the basis of performance over this qualifying tournament, not over the past 20 years or whatever they're planning to use.
That way, as you say, you'd be giving the best chance to the teams who've done the best - rather than teams who did the best in the past.
(2) More generally though, the point is that you should always, always decide these rules in advance. It's not as if they couldn't have foreseen that there would be play-offs, and they'd have to decide who played who somehow.
Announcing rules late on - which is what I assume they've done here - inevitably p*sses someone off, and gives the impression that they're favouring someone over someone else.
Why on earth werent the rules clear in advance? It's the equivalent of the football league announcing how this season's play-offs were going to work in March next year. Bizarre.
Posted By: Tricky Hawes on October 12th 2009 at 08:52:25
Message Thread
- Football's dead (Other Football) - Tombs, Oct 12, 08:23:08
- what a load of bo**ocks (Other Football) - mr carra, Oct 12, 08:45:32
- Don't fully agree with that, altho almost (Other Football) - Tricky Hawes, Oct 12, 08:52:25
- Agree about the timing being cra*p (Other Football) - mr carra, Oct 12, 09:13:00
- I do think there's a sense in which using the same seedings twice (Other Football) - Tricky Hawes, Oct 12, 09:19:28
- are they, though? (Other Football) - mr carra, Oct 12, 10:04:56
- I agree entirely. They had the advantage of avoiding the other 'big' nations, so should (Other Football) - megson, Oct 12, 09:44:18
- I do think there's a sense in which using the same seedings twice (Other Football) - Tricky Hawes, Oct 12, 09:19:28
- Agree about the timing being cra*p (Other Football) - mr carra, Oct 12, 09:13:00
- Don't fully agree with that, altho almost (Other Football) - Tricky Hawes, Oct 12, 08:52:25
- Good idea in my opinion. Gets rid of more of the shit. (n/m) (Other Football) - Steve in Holland, Oct 12, 08:35:28
- what a load of bo**ocks (Other Football) - mr carra, Oct 12, 08:45:32
Reply to Message
In order to add a post to the WotB Message Board you must be a registered WotB user.
If you are not yet registered then please visit the registration page. You should ensure that their browser is setup to accept cookies.