eh? I thought that was the point of this thread

people taking a pop at Healy (and so kind of defending NW) for his quote above

you suggested - reasonably - that you could view this as being similar to Hucks & Roeder, and yet people here are taking the opposite side

I just pointed out that a big difference is that Hucks has never criticised GR publically, whereas Healy now has.

What's unreasonable about any of that?

Posted By: Tricky Hawes, Dec 9, 12:00:12