Not according to a couple of my spurs mates

I have watched a number of times and they go every week and we all agree that he tries to be the playmaker, but he doesnt act as a defensive barrier whatsoever.

He doesnt make tackles and he doesnt protect the back four. If you want someone to do that then carrick isnt the man for the job.

Posted By: earlydoors, May 30, 10:59:36