You are entitled to your opinion, of course

But the football industry clearly rates Gibson as 'better'.

Player A
PL apps = 67
Twice promoted from Champs (as a regular starter)
England @ U17, U18, U20, U21 and full (squad)
Highest market value = £15m

Player B
PL apps = 0
Once promoted from tier 3 (as a regular starter)
England - never selected at any level
Highest market value = £3m

Posted By: Henclrikus, Oct 4, 19:25:44