How am I wrong?

Malky never beat a Prem side while playing for Norwich, even when those Prem sides were struggling in their own division. Fact
Pardew bought other defenders he thought would do a better job than Malky in the Prem. Fact
Malky has just got promoted again. Fact.

The subjective bit is that keeping Malky would have made us better as a Prem side. I think it wouldn't have, while others disagree.

In one year's time, if Malky has played 25 games for Watford & they stay up, I'll be proven wrong. Until then there are only opinions.

Posted By: jayson blair, May 22, 11:07:04