I'm really not sure

Maddison was absolutely incredible in that one season. Great assists, wonder goals, absolutely running the show from midfield. And he has carried on looking an excellent player at one of the best clubs in the Prem.

Buendia has been amazing in the Championship as well, but was a bit inconsistent in the Prem, and was pretty anonymous in our bad run at the end of the season. I'm convinced he and the rest of the team will do much better next season, but it's not absolutely guaranteed.

I'd happily pay extra to watch either - just don't know which would be better for us in the Prem. I'm sure that if Maddison were our current player and we had sold Buendia three years ago, a lot of the responses in this thread would be different.

Posted By: Mecagoenti, May 21, 10:01:11