I'd go for this as the criteria

Longest serving: Wes
Getting better the older he gets: Wes
Favorite player to watch for 90 mins: Wes
Most exciting: Hucks
Best leader: Holt
Best goalscorer: Holt
POTS: Holt
Most promotions and longest period in the Prem: Wes

So Wes slightly edges it

Posted By: roedtonowhere, Aug 1, 22:36:57