Intent is not relevant. For me it's whether or not he was challenging for the ball

ISTM that if a challenge, then red. But if merely a reckless attempt to control the ball, then yellow. Not sure Nani saw him so probably yellow (as he can't be challenging a player he's not seen). I could be wrong though.

Manure fans blaming the ref. Whodathunkit, eh?

Posted By: Old Man, Mar 6, 08:58:16