You said- "My argument was always that he nicked a goal when we 3-0 down
which mattered nothing to anything"
However, I have to point out that Earnshaw's goals earned us 9 points in 05/06 from 15 games and he also earned us 12 points from 30 games in 06/07. It's also fair to say that he didn't just nick a goal when we were losing because only 6 of his goals for Norwich (from 27) were scored in matches that we lost. Details.
The "he was detrimental to the teams he played for due to his selfishness" (paraphrasing) thing is also silly because you have to account for many different factors such as bad defending, as other have said.
Posted By: Common Sense Police, Jan 22, 16:42:45
Written & Designed By Ben Graves 1999-2025