We know we differ on this

If you read what I posted carefully as opposed to wading in with your argument boots pulled up and reading to kick, I said that I had no idea how Nelson would perform, but that we did know how Doherty would. So restating this, as a result I found it odd that people were so quick to make a conclusion to the negative for one, and the positive for the other. Just as you are doing. There are plenty of players who have been in a division for ages and actually bumble along in it; if Doc had stayed at Luton my hunch is he would probably have contined to ply his trade at that level. May have been better, but probably nothing that would instantly make people pick him out as a CHampionship star. If we extrapolated your approach, we should now be getting rid of Oli Johnson but keeping Jamie Cureton. See.

Posted By: camcan, May 17, 11:14:45