Disagree.

I think Earnshaw offers a predatory goalscorer with an average all round game.

Nugent is alot better all round; but won't score the same number of goals as Earnshaw. Nugent's youth is an advantage, but Earnshaw is only 26; that's still a good 6 years of in-his-prime Earnshaw.

If Nugent/Ashton/Johnson are worth between £7-8mil, then IMO Earnshaw is worth £6mil easily.

Posted By: LincolnshireCanary on June 22nd 2007 at 11:28:39

Message Thread

Sharp 'impressed'. But Waggers (in fact 'Haylett') now talking about Eastwood again (NCFC) - Tricky Hawes, Jun 22, 11:19:12
- Preston have accepted two £7mil offers for Nugent. (NCFC) - LincolnshireCanary, Jun 22, 11:22:38
  - Sadly True..Especially If Sharp does want to live up t'North. (n/m) (NCFC) - Auckland Rob, Jun 22, 11:34:07
  - If Marlon Harewood is worth 4m, Darren Bent Worth 17m (NCFC) - DiscoDaleGordon, Jun 22, 11:31:42
  - Nah... Earnie £5m tops, Nugent is younger will improve & has better all round game (n/m) (NCFC) - Taxi 4 Johnson, Jun 22, 11:23:44
    - Disagree. (NCFC) - LincolnshireCanary, Jun 22, 11:28:39
      - Earnshaw is nowhere near as good as... (NCFC) - NoReevesNoFuture, Jun 22, 11:32:02
        
        Nugent has been pants in the last 3 games I've seen him play. (NCFC) - Dog, Jun 22, 11:36:56
        
        how many times... (NCFC) - NoReevesNoFuture, Jun 22, 11:40:52
        
        True. (NCFC) - Dog, Jun 22, 11:44:41
      - Also Earnie has scored in The Prem - so less risk than Nugent (n/m) (NCFC) - Commisar_Canary, Jun 22, 11:32:01

Reply to Message

In order to add a post to the WotB Message Board you must be a registered WotB user.

If you are not yet registered then please visit the registration page. You should ensure that their browser is setup to accept cookies.