so Hughes IS worth ?500k?

your formula only applies to the selling club.

Carrick is worth ?19m to Spurs because that's what they can get for him. Doesn't mean it is what he is worth to Man U - only what he cost them. What he is worth to Man U will only transpire over time. It might be what they THINK he is worth but that isn't the same as actual worth.

Posted By: mr carra on July 31st 2006 at 10:36:33

Message Thread

19m for Carrick?!? (Other Football) - DiscoDaleGordon, Jul 31, 10:23:55
- ?15m plus add ons BUT ?12m came from Chelsea for a lad who never played for Man Ure! (Other Football) - Commisar_Canary, Jul 31, 12:43:44
- man u paid 28 million for veron once!? (n/m) (Other Football) - strap_on sally, Jul 31, 10:29:04
  - they certainly did (n/m) (Other Football) - SCC 26, Jul 31, 10:30:14
  - That was before they were millions in debt (Other Football) - DiscoDaleGordon, Jul 31, 10:29:52
- You'll hear fans of man u and liverpool complaining they don't (Other Football) - pants, Jul 31, 10:27:15
  - They havent spent on the same level as chelsea in the past 3 or 4 years (n/m) (Other Football) - earlydoors, Jul 31, 10:58:51
- if man u win the prem of champions league (Other Football) - strap_on sally, Jul 31, 10:26:33
  - They paid ?20m for SWP (Other Football) - conker, Jul 31, 10:29:33
  - Do you think Man U will though? (Other Football) - DiscoDaleGordon, Jul 31, 10:28:04
    - to be honest, i don't know who will win the prem (Other Football) - strap_on sally, Jul 31, 10:36:18
      - I saw 2 to 1 on for Chelsea, which is a bargain (Other Football) - conker, Jul 31, 10:37:59
    - Think liverpool will be the ones to come good (Other Football) - pants, Jul 31, 10:29:37
      - their top scorer has left and hasn't been replaced as yet (n/m) (Other Football) - mr carra, Jul 31, 10:33:25
        
        that's Man U's not Liverpool's (n/m) (Other Football) - mr carra, Jul 31, 10:33:56
        
        Saha and Ole are injury prone (Other Football) - DiscoDaleGordon, Jul 31, 10:35:09
        
        Rooney isn't a prolific goalscorer anyway (Other Football) - mr carra, Jul 31, 10:37:11
        
        True (Other Football) - DiscoDaleGordon, Jul 31, 10:40:06
        
        And he looks like Shrek, which I know isn't news to anyone... (Other Football) - Fierce Panda, Jul 31, 10:37:57
- nah (Other Football) - SCC 26, Jul 31, 10:24:56
  - No one else wants him as he is not that good (Other Football) - DiscoDaleGordon, Jul 31, 10:26:37
    - did ok for england against ecuador (Other Football) - SCC 26, Jul 31, 10:28:08
      - OK, but nothing special (Other Football) - mr carra, Jul 31, 10:32:20
    - He's OK... (Other Football) - Fierce Panda, Jul 31, 10:28:02
      - Yeah hes OK (Other Football) - DiscoDaleGordon, Jul 31, 10:30:47
    - A player is worth what another club will pay for him... (Other Football) - Brom, Jul 31, 10:27:46
      - so Hughes IS worth ?500k? (Other Football) - mr carra, Jul 31, 10:36:33
        
        At the time we bought him, Andy Hughes was worth 500k... (Other Football) - Brom, Jul 31, 10:38:42
        
        key point - we THOUGHT he was worth ?500k (Other Football) - mr carra, Jul 31, 10:42:53
        
        I (and probably most others) understand your emphasis... (Other Football) - DJ Ginga, Jul 31, 10:47:52
        
        No... (Other Football) - Brom, Jul 31, 10:49:58
        
        you are right, but only to the club RECEIVING the payment (Other Football) - mr carra, Jul 31, 10:57:43
        
        Fair play for admitting that (n/m) (Other Football) - DJ Ginga, Jul 31, 10:54:24
        
        'we THOUGHT he was worth ?500k' (Other Football) - Brom, Jul 31, 10:43:48
        
        no it isn't - it's what he was worth to Reading (Other Football) - mr carra, Jul 31, 10:49:11
        
        He was worth 500k to us... (Other Football) - Brom, Jul 31, 10:51:33
        
        I have... (Other Football) - Fierce Panda, Jul 31, 10:41:29
        
        However all gaseous releases from yourself are now minty fresh (n/m) (Other Football) - conker, Jul 31, 10:42:39
        
        Depends on how desperate you were to buy that particular thing (n/m) (Other Football) - conker, Jul 31, 10:40:08
        
        But your desperation would increase the value of that item to you (n/m) (Other Football) - Brom, Jul 31, 10:43:03
        
        An example would be Ebay (Other Football) - conker, Jul 31, 10:46:41
        
        uber quack (n/m) (Other Football) - conker, Jul 31, 10:48:12
        
        An example would be Ebay (Other Football) - conker, Jul 31, 10:46:41
        
        An example would be Ebay (Other Football) - conker, Jul 31, 10:46:41
        
        The point is you WANT it... (Other Football) - Brom, Jul 31, 10:47:46
        
        So Worthy WANTED Hughes, regardless of how much he paid (Other Football) - conker, Jul 31, 10:50:00
        
        So Worthy WANTED Hughes, regardless of how much he paid (Other Football) - conker, Jul 31, 10:50:00
        
        That is pure speculation... (Other Football) - Brom, Jul 31, 10:52:17
        
        Most of the posts on the board are speculation! (Other Football) - conker, Jul 31, 10:53:52
        
        Wasn't ineffective when he scored against Leeds (n/m) (Other Football) - Brom, Jul 31, 10:57:32
        
        500k per goal then (Other Football) - conker, Jul 31, 11:00:10
        
        *25ok (n/m) (Other Football) - conker, Jul 31, 11:00:22
        
        So Worthy WANTED Hughes, regardless of how much he paid (Other Football) - conker, Jul 31, 10:49:59
        
        Hmm (n/m) (Other Football) - conker, Jul 31, 10:50:25
        
        Spaz (n/m) (Other Football) - Brom, Jul 31, 10:52:25
        
        It's not my fault that it duplicates my posts (n/m) (Other Football) - conker, Jul 31, 10:54:44
        
        Blub (n/m) (Other Football) - Brom, Jul 31, 10:57:39
      - that's a fantastic formula (Other Football) - SCC 26, Jul 31, 10:29:08
        
        Thanks Mike (n/m) (Other Football) - Brom, Jul 31, 10:30:48

Reply to Message

In order to add a post to the WotB Message Board you must be a registered WotB user.

If you are not yet registered then please visit the registration page. You should ensure that their browser is setup to accept cookies.