Great bloke, great talker, great honesty but is he a great manager?

Have a huge amount of respect for Alex Neil the way he handled himself last night but being a decent man, taking honestly, admitting his mistakes etc does not make him a good manager. In my eyes and in his by the sound of it He has to shoulder a lot of blame for this season although a lot of fans seem to want to exonerate him of any blame at all.

The truth will come out next season to an extent and if he does get us back up the following season in the prem whether his play off promotion last year was the start of a special managerial career or the high point of an average managerial career. Is he the next big thing or is he the next Aidy Boithroyd, Iain Dowie, Phil Brown etc.

Only time will tell whether he learns from his considerable mistakes, refinds his beliefs, sticks to them and kicks on as a manager.

I fully understand why so many fans respect him as he is appears to be a fantastic human being which is a rare thing in football nowadays. However he still has it all to prove in footballing terms. A lot of posts I have seen and comments on CC last say how we are so lucky to have him. Alternative to this I would hope he thinks how lucky he is to be at such a club as NCFC. I don't believe currently He would not get a job at any other club similar in size to us in terms of fanbase etc and I think he would have come under a lot more pressure at any other club during this season.He certainly would not have been given so much respect as he was by the fans last night at other clubs.

It's over to you know Alex, have a quick break, reenergise yourself and come back refreshed and ready to show you have learned from your mistakes and that you deserve to be manager of our great club in a footballing sense not just as a human being.

Nothing but top 2 will do next season in my eyes.

Posted By: happy clappy hughes on May 12th 2016 at 07:20:30

Message Thread

Great bloke, great talker, great honesty but is he a great manager? (NCFC) - happy clappy hughes, May 12, 07:20:30
- Potentially some day yes. He is doing his YTS apprentice scheme with us (NCFC) - essexcanaryOTBC, May 12, 10:18:03
- Not yet. Realistically, who'd imagine he could be successful in the Premier League with so (NCFC) - Higher Wrather, May 12, 07:38:28
  - Yes he was and now we pay the price for it (NCFC) - Mickdundee, May 12, 08:51:34
- Exactly. Only time will tell. (NCFC) - mr carra, May 12, 07:32:15
- He has a lot to learn he's admitted that but that's half the battle isn't it? (NCFC) - Taxi 4 Johnson, May 12, 07:29:39
  - I have criticised him but.,, (NCFC) - colincanary, May 12, 07:46:10
  - Is definitely a good start (NCFC) - happy clappy hughes, May 12, 07:32:20
    - He's not someone who just talks the talk. Come on. (n/m) (NCFC) - essexcanaryOTBC, May 12, 10:18:41
  - A few typos but u get my point (n/m) (NCFC) - Taxi 4 Johnson, May 12, 07:30:03

Reply to Message

In order to add a post to the WotB Message Board you must be a registered WotB user.

If you are not yet registered then please visit the registration page. You should ensure that their browser is setup to accept cookies.